Husbands and Wives play Dil Kabaddi

Posted by Anantha | Posted in , , , , , , , | Posted on Thursday, April 23, 2009

4

Saw Dil KabaDDi few days back; thoroughly enjoyed it. I thought it was the best 'Romantic Adult Comedy' I have seen in Hindi. I found the screenplay fresh, neat narration, excellent pool of talented actors and hilarious dialogues, only to realize later when Saravanan pointed out that Dil KabaDDi is blatantly ripped off from Woody Allen’s Husbands and Wives. I watched Husbands and Wives the very next day. I was shocked. Dil KabaDDi is almost a Hindi translation of HAW. Dialogue writer of DK has shown his credibility in English to Hindi translation. Or did he just get the Hindi subtitles of HAW and provided a printout of the same to the actors while acting/rehearsing? One could notice the finger count of differences between the two movies.

Having said that I would also like to say it is a very rare thing to happen for a ripped-off movie to come out more enjoyable than the original! DK is one such movie!!

Husbands and Wives
Dir: Woody Allen
Cast: Woody Allen, Mia Farrow, Sydney Pollack and Judy Davis

This is the first Woody Allen movie I have seen. After reading/hearing a lot about him, I witnessed his style of film making in HAW. In the beginning of the movie, many of the scenes are long shots, actors speaking to each other for long without breaking, cinematographer moving along with the characters; My eyes usually take time to get adjusted to the camera, when it is moving between the characters, dodging the shoulders and heads of actors (if they are also moving along the camera), maneuvering not to hit the static objects in the scene. But at the same time it gives an impression to the audience as if they are dropped right in between the characters, which is very nice.

It revolves around 2 couples, Gabe, Judie and Jack, Sally. The story revolves around infidelity, adultery and about their unsure decisions they take in life, letting them split, re-unite, live apart, find another companion etc. Though it is being categorized as a comedy movie, I hardly smiled at any of the (if any) jokes in the movie. May be I am not of the types who laughs for Woody Allen type of jokes.

I also felt, all the lead actors were too old to deal with these marital problems; well that’s purely my personal opinion.


Dil Kabaddi
Dir: Anil Senior
Cast: Irrfan Khan, Soha Ali Khan, Konkona Sen Sharma and Rahul Bose

Dil Kabaddi opens with one of my favorite scenes in the movie. Irrfan starts with a monologue on love. Speaking about to what extent people go crazy for love, he continues, "boss, bees saal tak ek hi building ko banwaana koi mazaak kaam nahin hain, woh bhi ek hi color main.. banaane ke liye patience chaahiye. Shah Jahan bawra nahin ho gaya tha buddy.. marble pe marble kharch kar daala, kaay ke liye..? true love, sachcha pyaar.. ruh se ruh ka milan... wahh.. but then... times changed... ". Irrfan’s voice gets sidelined in the noise of ringing phones.. sound of horn, vehicular movement, traffic chaos.

Samit played by Irrfan is an on-the-edge-eccentric kind of guy, who thinks it is style to wear sun glasses while driving the car in the night. Who wears silver grayish tie for a bright pink+blue striped formal shirts, has a penchant for kinky sex, also thinks his body-brain balance is screwed up because he is sex starved. Check out another gem of a dialogue by Samit, "bed room ke under kya hota hain usse romance ka kya lena dena... woh bhi husband and wife ke beech main….. husbands and wives are beyond romance”. Well, that's Samit for you :) Add to this, the unique dialogue delivery style, his mumbles, deliberate repetition of words, that makes Irrfan Khan THE BEST guy to play the role of Samit.

Soha Ali Khan is surprisingly refreshing in the role of Mita (Irrfan’s wife). Though Irrfan and Soha look very odd as a pair, but that is the exact requirement of the script to have a couple who are not so alike, who make an odd pair. The other couple, played by Konkona and Rahul Bose suit the role of Rishi and Simi at their best. Payal Rohatgi has overplayed the role as a dumb bimbette. Though Rahul Khanna has nothing much to do, has done justice to the role.

Even after copying scene to scene from HAW, the director of DK, Anil Senior deserves a mention for the portrayal of subtle man-woman relationships (in the very few original scenes of the movie). In both the movies, a narrator guy keeps questioning / prodding the characters to speak out to the camera. No better way to spill out the insecurities, idiosyncrasies and confusions about the relationships of the characters than this. I enjoyed it.

Though portraying all the men as creatures who think between their legs is questionable, I would recommend this movie to all the people who love laughing on this vice of men.

Adventure sports is not all that fun

Posted by Anantha | Posted in | Posted on Monday, April 13, 2009

7

My friend and ex-teammate Satish called me up on SAT night around 8:30 and asked me to switch to TV9. News reader was reading out the tragic incident of Bhargava, who had met with an unfortunate death trying reverse Bungee jump near Bannerghatta National Park. For me name of the adventure club was as shocking as the incident itself. The flash news read, the Bungee jump was jointly organised by CARE* and Head Rush adventure sports club. Satish on the other end said, 'remember the name CARE?', I uttered in shock, 'Ohh shit..'.

I think it was nearly an year ago, Satish and me with few other friends had tried parasailing near Kolar, which was organised by the same organization, CARE. I remember it was an open field [I think it was a big lake before] where the event was organised. There was absolutely no ambulance organised by CARE, nor did they have any first-aid kits!! I don't even think they had valid license to conduct such an adventure sporting event that day also. More shockingly before the flight, each one of us signed a printed copy which stated**, 'I _____, hereby declare that I am fully aware of the risks and injuries caused by this adventure sports. Organisers are not responsible for any kind of injuries or mishap'!!!!!

We were given a demo by one of the professionals there and we blindly had signed that copy. How foolish were we to sign that! All of us had risked our lives for few minutes of adrenalin rush. Though nothing went wrong that day, but any thing could have happened.... 

No doubt these kind of organizers should be severely punished, I also insist Govt to conduct an investigation to verify the valid license of all the so called adventure clubs all over the state. I also would like plea to all the adventure enthusiasts out there not to try these adventure sports without adequate safety measures.

* careindia.in is shutdown. Expected eh..
** It is not the exact text, but that was the intended message

Revised blogroll

Posted by Anantha | Posted on Thursday, April 09, 2009

8

As you guys might have observed by this time, I revised the Blogroll for my blog. It is like cleaning the desktop, lot of old and unused things had piled up. Cleansed up all such links and now I have categorized the blogroll as the blogs I often visit and comment, photo blogs, few very very interesting Kannada sites and also few sites about Movies.

Hope you guys like it..

My graphiti

Posted by Anantha | Posted in , | Posted on Saturday, April 04, 2009

8

There are some of the things that are best represented in graphs than in words

funny pictures



funny pictures



funny pictures



funny pictures




funny pictures

PS: These graphs are heuristic, based on my current take on the world

Friday comedy - a drama

Posted by Anantha | Posted in , , | Posted on Friday, March 13, 2009

12

[Sutradhar speaks, “This is a satirical take on the status meeting in my previous project. Addressing my team mates with their mother land or mother tongue is not meant to hurt any one’s feelings. It should be taken in the right sense. I prefer this way than addressing a person by a single alphabet. Not only it sounds weird to hear ‘P sat next to W who was speaking to J about D’, it is quite confusing also.
All the characters in the drama are my ex teammates made of flesh and blood, resemblance to any dead person is purely coincidental. Though I had written this script many months back, did not dared to post this script, otherwise my appraisal ratings would have got affected. So, here I start.. Hope you enjoy this one”. Curtain opens, audience applaud]



It was a practice in our team to have a status meeting every Friday exactly at 1:30 PM. This is the dais for us to confess our failures of the past week, to boast about our achievements in front of the whole team, to blame one another for each others’ failures. Hope you got the enough intro on this comedy drama.

Let me introduce you all the characters one by one.

EM : acronym for Engg Mangr. We have to plea to the same guy for our appraisals and sick leaves. Hence a very important person, With whom you can not take punga

PM : an obvious acronym. This guy is supposed to control the events of the Fri comedy. Has a docile voice which contradicts the purpose of his role

TL : obvious acronym. A knowledgeable guy, who feels he is the Atlas who carries the project on his shoulders [nevertheless to say, who feels PM doesn't know the head n tail of the on going project]

Supporting cast:

Bihari babu : He speaks English in Bhojpuri

Oriya guy : with long hair, always gives complex to the other 2 females in the team

Female-1 and Female-2: PM mellows down when he asks status to these gals

A Mallu - whose second name belongs to the world's toughest tongue twister's list

Tamailian-1 and Tamilian-2: Tamilian-1’s face always reflects the pain of losing the race to the post of TL to the existing TL, Tamilian-2 always bears an im-under-utilized-in-the-team-u-see look

A Geek :
who always makes sure his sentences contain at least 2-3 words which nobody understands in the team. And gives a wry smile after finishing every sentence

A guy from Nagpur : Has a very juvenile face. Some day I want to see this guy dressed up in a school uniform, with blue checkered shirt and plain blue shorts with a hankey pinned to his shirt

And then there is me, the Sutradhar – Sutradhar agrees with the saying, ‘team meeting is where we conclude that none of us is as worse than all of us together’

OK enough of introduction, its time to start the drama now.

It was already 1:40 and no clue of meeting still. OK at last every one started heading towards the meeting room. There was sudden tension in the air, the PM noticed that the meeting room booked by him is occupied by some other biggies from the higher management. But PM felt it is too ridiculous a reason to cancel the meeting. Soon he found another empty one and we all march towards that empty room as per his directions. We occupied the seats in hurry. By the time PM connected his laptop to the OHP [overhead projector - it has always lived up to its name by causing considerable overhead from connecting the laptop to zooming and focusing onto the screen] it was 10 to two. Tamilian-1, Geek and Oriya guy were yet to come. At the beginning of the meeting PM informed us that EM would not be able to attend that day's meeting as he was busy with some other work. Some of us sighed in relief. But there was a price we had to pay for his absence. That is a proloooooooonged meeting. EM has a good habit of talking and making us talk to the point. The team gets unruly in EM's absence. When I mean unruly, I never meant I liked the team to be ruled by some one like EM... ok.. Let me re-phrase it.. shall I say team mates behave self-managed in EM's presence... hey, but this became an oxymoron. How can you call some one self-managed when he behaves so only in some body else's vigilance... ha ha. Forget it hope you got what I wanted to say. Some things are better explained by what they are not than what they are. This was one such thing.

“Ok..”, PM opened the Status tracker Excel sheet intending to start the meeting. He continued, “what is the status of this tagging work..”, turning to Mallu. If you are wondering what is this tagging thing, do not worry. No one in our team is clear about it, including our Mallu who is working on it.
Mallu just opened his mouth to speak.. Geek, Oriya guy and Tamilian-1 entered the meeting room disturbing the whole ambiance. Each one of them hunted for an empty chair.. but found none. They had to be content standing in the meeting room.

Geek had an apple in his hand. May be he wanted the PM to understand that he has skipped his lunch. His hair always remained tousled. The harder he works, the more tousled it gets. I feel there is a jaani dushmani between his hair and all the combs in the world. Geek said, “I was just replying to Johan’s mail”, sounding an explanation for his late entry for the meeting. Tamilian-1 and Oriya guy did not bother to give an explanation, neither did PM ask. If you are wondering who this Johan is, do not worry again. Think he is a gora sitting in London, our client guy. You can replace Johan with any English cricketer or footballer you know, no body would mind. Some day even I want to enter the meeting room saying, “sorry.. I was just having a chat with Kevin Pieterson about our team’s performance in the last quarter”.

Mallu found a Milli second of time interval and opened his mouth to throw up his updates… but geek had his own plans of interrupting the flow of the meeting. He said to PM, “can you just check my reply to Johan.. I have put you in the loop too”.

May be PM also felt it was more important to see what the Geek has replied to him. He opened his mail box. And I started glancing the subject lines of all his mails. I expected his mailbox to contain mails with subject lines like, ‘Katrina new photos - CRFL’ or ‘Mumbai girls playing Holi’ OR ‘sard jokes – new collection’. But I found none of that kind except all project related crappy mails. His life must be as colorless, spice less the way he looks. He opened the mail by Geek to Johan, read the first few lines and pretended as if he understood the idea proposed by Geek. And said “this should be fine..”, continued, “lets wait for his reply..”, in a diplomatic tone.

How could a TL keep quiet in such a situation, which demands his explanation and enlightening solution for the problem. He uttered the cause of this issue, even showed a glimpse of his foresightedness saying he had expected this to happen some 70 Yrs back. PM nodded in agreement to his solution. Oriya guy caught every one’s attention by saying “is issue ko mera code change merge karne se kuch pharak padega na..?”, combing his long hair with the tips of his fingers. He uses our Rashtra bhasha liberally even in the team meetings. Nobody has a problem with that, but we had a problem with where the hell was meeting going towards? What the hell was meeting for? Geek said, “No… ur code change addresses a totally different issue”. Oriya guy looked happy with that statement of the Geek.

At last Mallu guy stole a micro second of silence this time and started reporting his progress. He had a mission accomplished kinda expression on his face, once he finished speaking. Then it was the turn of the Female-1 to talk abt her achievements or misdemeanors in the last week. This female has a habit of jilebi-ying any given topic [which means beating around the bush]. I was following her till she spoke her third sentence, then I got lost in one of the sharp curves of the jilebi. I started looking blankly at the other blank faces in the room. Then that pretty girl from the other team happened to pass off our meeting room. I thanked the guy who designed the glass walls of our meeting rooms. What I like about that pretty girl is the way she walks, with letting her hair sway in the air. Unknowingly my head traversed an arch of 270 degrees, till she went out of sight. Soon I became conscious if any body had noticed my traverse, I looked around to see Bihari babu also following her walk. I smirked at Bihari babu. Knowing that he was caught leching, maintained his dignified posture continuing listening to Female-1’s status report.

Tamilian-2 controlled his burp, it could have sounded less louder if he had let his burp pass. He does this very often. May be the gastric problem u see.. I just thought, the day somebody invents that burp-gas is combustible and could be used as substitute for LPG, this guy would become millionaire, man. Female-2 was examining her nail polish closely. If she had given 10% of this attention while coding, she would have been the most productive person in our team after geek. TL was not finding the gap to poke his nose in between. He was fiddling his beard.

“We have borne a lot of pressure in the last release…”, PM’s words sailed in air and happened to enter my ears. I could see he had felt the word ‘pressure’. I really get pity when some one with meek voice uttering the word ‘pressure’ in the post lunch hour. I am damn sure the word ‘pressure’ originated directly from his bowels. Why are you laughing, after all he is also a human being, it can happen to any one after the heavy lunch on a week day. Nobody understood his expression except me. PM continued the status meeting with his constipated looks.

I don’t know whose bright idea was to put Team Outing as one of the action items in the excel sheet. When every one saw this as the next item to be discussed, every one of us waited like a tiger waiting for its prey near the stream. I know the moment PM utters team Outing, there would be an endless conversation. Every one in the team suggested all the tourist spots around Bangalore as if it is their birth right to visit that place. I even heard some one suggesting UK for team outing, may be some soul which was longing for an on site trip. But it was fun to hear that. Every one of us bursted into hearty laughter. Then guy from Nagpur suggested to take this topic off line. Every one nodded their heads. That Nagpur guy acknowledged as it was his best suggestion given to any one in his whole life.

It was already 3:40 and my turn had not come still to explain my inventions of the last week. My mind just thought posting this meeting comedy in my blog. My mind started thinking of a good title for my post. I thought of few titles, by then heard a voice calling my name. It kinda brought me back to the reality of the meeting room. PM was demanding me to give the status of last week. I told him convincingly that my coding of few lines was the next best invention after Edison’s bulb. Though every one did not agree to that, but every one agreed that I was successful in bamboozling the PM.

I even observed that Geek and Oriya guy had disappeared from the room, giving an excuse of handling some urgent submissions may be. But I bet both would be found in smoking zone. As I had finished giving my status, I just uttered a word ‘excuse me’ holding my cell in hand and walked out of the room. This is an additional feature of my phone called walk-out-of-unwanted-meeting. Nagpur guy was chaloo enough to understand that I had never got a call. But who cares.. I just walked out the drama.

This drama will be screened every FRI…

Movie mania

Posted by Anantha | Posted in , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Posted on Friday, February 20, 2009

6

Im on a movie watching spree like never before. To be precise I have watched 13 movies in last 1 month!! I know there are movie maniacs out there who watch a movie every day, but 13 in 30 days is still a whopping number for me. I am impatient to write a review/comment on each one of them in separate posts, though some of them deserve at least a post on them.

So I here I write few lines about those movies.


Slumdog Millionaire
Dir: Danny Boyle
Cast: Dev Patel, Freida Pinto
Much has been written and discussed about this movie. Keeping aside the flaws; it is a very good entertainer. Kudos to Simon Beaufoy for an excellent adaptation of the novel by Vikas Swarup. I read the book,
Q and A too which is not as good as the movie.
The disgusting cesspit scene of the movie tops my list of 'Most disgusting scenes ever in cinema'. Guess the 2nd and 3rd in the list, they are from the movie,
Trainspotting again by Danny Boyle!! 2nd best being a stupored lead actor defecating on the bed in his GF's house, 3rd being Ewan McGregor diving in to the commode of the filthiest toilet of Scotland. But, however disgusting the scenes might be, I still love Danny Boyle's movies! :)

Lake House
Dir: Alejandro Agresti
Cast: Sandra Bullock, Keanu Reeves
Watched it after Ethapay reco'd this to me. A nice romantic story with a mysterious time difference of 2 years that separates the lead actors. Liked it in parts. Watchable for the very idea of the screenplay.

Raaz – The mystery continues
Dir: Mohit Suri
Cast: Emraan Hashmi, Kangana Ranaut, Adhyayan Suman
I watched this in theatre. Quite gripping and scary too in places.

Salaam Bombay!
Dir: Mira Nair
I had not commented when people said Salaam Bombay is the best portrayal of Indian slums and a better movie than Slumdog. Watched it just for the sake of it. Believe me, I could not tolerate the movie for more than 45 minutes from its beginning. I know the lead actors are kids from slums, but I simply could not feel empathy for the characters who just can not emote a single scene well. It just does not bother me when a character in the movie is dying in boiling oil in hell with an eternal wooden expression on their face. No special accolades for then not so established actors like Nana Patekar, Irfan Khan and Raghvir Yadav too.

It might be considered a good documentary in my opinion. IMHO, Slumdog is a way better movie, technically, screenplay wise, direction wise, cast wise and background score wise. I do not wanna praise Salaam Bombay just because Mira Nair is Indian.


BubbleShare: Share photos - Easy Photo Sharing


Before the rains
Dir: Santosh Sivan
Cast: Linus Roache, Rahul Bose, Nandita Das
This is an Indo-British collaboration. I am not sure whether this movie got released in India or not. Picked this one up only because of Santhosh Sivan and the movie did not disappoint me at all. The movie is 'painted' on the canvas of Kerala by Sivan. Neat performances by all the lead actors and an awesome handling of the subject by Sivan. Watch it. 

Wrestler
Dir: Darren Aronofsky
Cast: Mickey Rourke, Marisa Tomei
This is one of the best movies I have seen in recent times. Thanks to Ashwin for giving me the DVD. I dint know who
Mickey Rourke was until I saw this movie and now he is there right on top of my favourite actors list. I simply loved his performance in this movie. I hope he wins Best Actor award in this year's Oscars (Sean Penn for Milk will be a strong contender too).

The story of Wrestler is about Randy 'The Ram' Robinson, a wrestler in the descent of his glorious years in the ring. He is old now, his ageing body will no more bear steroids and sustain on pain killers, he has a daughter who lives apart and hates him immensely and he does not know any thing but wrestling for his livelihood. He often visits a strip club and shares his thoughts and emotionally connects to a middle aged stripper named Casidy (Marisa Tomei). Casidy is no more a young and voluptuous stripper in the club, her skin is sagging, and teenage boys humiliate her when she offers a lapdance. Once, after a brutal fight in the ring, Randy collapses in the locker room of heavy heart attack. Undergoes a bye pass surgery and is advised by doctor not to continue wrestling at the stake of his life.

The portrayal of these miserable souls, the emotions they undergo and the choices they make in their lives make the movie immensely adorable. Don't miss this one.


Luck by Chance
Dir: Zoya Akhtar
Cast: Farhan Akhtar, Konkona Sen Sharma and a whole lot of cameos by Bollywood biggies
A satirical take on clichéd Bollywood, protagonists' struggle to stardom and a believable role the luck plays in shaping the protagonist's future. The self clowning acts by many cameos are surprisingly wonderful. A must-add DVD to the personal collection.

Dev.D
Dir: Anurag Kashyap
Cast: Abhay Deol, Kalki Koechlin, Mahi Gill
A bold and modern take on Devdas in quintessential Anurag Kashyap style.

I bet this is going to be the only movie that stands apart from rest of all the Devdas versions in various languages. An excellent act by Abhay Deol and new comer Mahi Gill. Though Kalki Koechlin suits well for the role of Chanda, a better rendition could have been possible by any other capable actor. Thank God Anurag Kashyap did not make it as cryptic as
No Smoking, still Dev.D is abstract enough in places. I wanna watch it again to connect the dots that are left over in my mind.

Curious case of Benjamin button
Sorry to say I was not impressed. Movie was not engaging for me.

7 pounds
Dir: Gabriele Muccino
Great performance by Will Smith, a well made movie. But, not as good as The pursuit of..

9 ½ weeks
Dir: Adrian Lyne
Cast: Mickey Rourke, Kim Bassinger
The movie is based on the erotic escapades of Mickey Rourke and Kim Bassinger in a duration of 9 ½ weeks. Watch it to see a charming and young Mickey Rourke (unlike in Wrestler) and hawwttt Kim Bassinger.

Elegy
Dir: Isabel Coixet
Cast: Ben Kingsley, Penelope Cruze
I picked this to see 'more of' my favorite actress Penelope Cruze. Ben Kingsley is charismatic as ever. This movie would not have been so special without these two actors.

Old Boy
Dir: Park Chan-wook
Cast: Choi Min-sik, Yu Ji-tae
Thanks to Ashwin again for giving me the DVD. This is a South Korean movie released in 2003.
I finished watching this movie at 2:15 AM last night. Could not bate my eye lids till 3 AM! This movie leaves you stirred, shocked and amazed! This is the 2nd of the
Vengeance Trilogy by the director Park Chan-wook. Im dying to watch the 1st and the 3rd part too, search for the DVDs in on.

Oh btw, Zinda starring Sanjay Dutt and John Abraham is based on this movie. Seeing the violence, brutal revenge plot of the original I am convinced Zinda would be a much softer version of Old Boy to fit in the frame of Bollywood, but I wanna watch it for the mere comparison's sake.


Slumdog Millionaire and the brouhaha

Posted by Anantha | Posted in , , , , , , | Posted on Friday, January 30, 2009

4

There has been plethora of debates, interviews, blog posts by celebs, comments and counter comments about the way Indian underbelly is depicted in the movie Slumdog Millionaire.

Before jumping into the debate, let me give you a fictitious analogy. Assume an acquaintance of yours drops into your home unexpectedly. The moment he enters the house, he observes nook and corner of your house with sheer curiosity of a newly arrived guest. He notices a huge cobweb in the corner of walls underneath your attic. Then in few other corners of your house too. Not only he notices, but also utters a word about untidiness of the house. What would be your reaction?
  • A. “It is my house; I can keep however dirty I wish it to be. If you have a problem with it, GET LOST! ”
  • B. “Oh come on! You visitors always point out such things in the house. Do u ever see beautiful antique furniture, the exotic vase with fresh flowers on the teapoy etc..?”
  • C. “Aah.. I cud not clean it as I can not reach there”
  • D. “You are saying it as if cobwebs do not get formed in your house!”
I hope you got the relevance of the analogy (quite lame though). Our reactions to Slumdog Millionaire or to any foreign filmmaker making a movie on the hard realities of India (that we are not so proud of) would fall into at least one of options A, B, C or D, mentioned above. Certainly there is an element of embarrassment when an ‘outsider’ points at the filth in our house.

Would our reactions be different if the movie had been directed by our own desi filmmaker?
Would our reactions be different if the movie had not hogged the limelight as it has done now with winning 4 Golden globes and earning 10 Oscar nominations?
Are we expressing the anger only because we are worried about the projection of India to the so called First World?
Why don’t we talk about Smile Pinky or The Final Inch [which are Oscar nominations for this year’s best short documentary films], which deal with similar themes?

In my opinion, after all Slumdog Millionaire is a fiction movie which deals with the hard realities of India. The movie might have exaggerated the slums and poverty in few places, but we can not deny the fact that Dharavi is the 2nd biggest slum in Asia (after Orangi Town in Karachi, Pakistan) and close to 1 million poor people of India live there in Dharavi. There have been movies in the past by Indian film makers which have dealt with similar subjects. Why should we treat Danny Boyle differently from Madhur Bhandarkar, Govind Nihalani and Mira Nair? 

If our concern is projection of India and the notions First World derives out of this, I say it is also India but not India in its entirety. Also how just it is to set our notions about a country watching the movies made on it? Or does any one ever refer to the movies or television series of a country to study the geography or history or politics or progress of that country for that matter? If yes, then it is as fair as presuming US as a land of teenage pregnancies after watching Juno, calling it a land of troubled families and pervert fathers after seeing American Beauty, To presume China as a land only about Martial Arts after watching innumerable famous Chinese movies, to presume Iran as the country where children wear torn shoes after watching Children of Heaven, to presume Brazil as the land of drug dealers after watching City of God and at last UK as land of racists after watching Big Brother! When firangs called India is a country of snake charmers, I laughed at their ignorance. My reaction would be no different if they now think Dharavi is India. 

You can only capture or understand a zilch of India in a fiction movie or a documentary. India is not only culturally and demographically diverse but also economically diverse. 
Forbes lists 4 Indians in the roster of top 10 richest men on earth, at the same time 300 million people leave below poverty line in India.
India can design PSLVs to reach Moon indigenously, but in rural areas there is no adequate transportation for kids to go to their schools.
Indian Pharmaceutical industry is one of the biggest exporters in the world with US$ 7.2 Billion (in 2007-08) but India is also known as Diabetes capital of World, It has close to 2.5 million HIV infected people, a source says the estimate of new cancer cases every year is 8 millions in India, which is one of the highest in the world.
IITs and IIMs are one of the best educational institutes in the world but the same country has innumerous Govt schools with no teachers and no proper facilities for children.
India is estimated to surpass China in population in 2030, but also India accounts for more than 20% of the global maternal and child deaths.
India has a varied caste system from Kashmir to Kanyakumari and boasts of unity in diversity but also accounts to thousands of barbaric deaths in the caste riots every year.

These are just few examples depicting poles-apart facts coexisting in this glorious country. There are things to be really proud of, there are also things that make us Indians cringe. So when there is an honest attempt of making a movie on hard to chew facts of India, do not banish the director or the movie. But when First World thinks India is a nation of slums and poverty, just laugh at their ignorance.

TOI columnist Santhosh Desai says very rightly in his last column of ‘Citi Citi Bang Bang’, “It was perhaps more understandable why we were touchy about the representation of Indian poverty 20 years ago. At that time, we feared that to be our unchanging reality and it made us deeply ashamed. Today, when we believe that India is on its way up, why do we still respond negatively?” These lines quite sum up my thoughts too.